Rex Martinich
A young Indigenous man’s missing persons case could have had a different outcome if police started searching earlier and followed all procedures, a coroner has heard.
Tallis Gordon Ahfat last saw his family members at Mount Isa, in Queensland’s remote north-west, at 4am on December 16, 2022.
Police were unable to find the 22-year-old despite a series of major searches involving helicopters, drones and divers, counsel assisting Sarah Ford previously told coroner Melinda Zerner.
The inquest into Ahfat’s disappearance resumed hearings in Brisbane on Thursday.
Zerner heard expert evidence from former Queensland police search and rescue co-ordinator and training officer Dr James Whitehead.
The shift supervising officer did not fully complete the paperwork when Ahfat’s family reported him missing, potentially closing off the option to start an immediate emergency search of his last known whereabouts.
“If they had started earlier, it would have given Tallis a greater chance of being found but I think the opportunity for finding him alive had already evaporated by the time he was reported missing,” Whitehead said.
The supervising officer might not have been aware that they needed to complete a search urgency form after Ahfat was reported as a high-risk missing person on December 19, Zerner heard.
“Mount Isa has a very high turnover of staff; a supervisor might not have any training in a supervisory role,” Whitehead said.
“It may be an acting senior constable just thrown in the job, ticking the boxes … It’s very hard to fill these remote places with people who want to be there.”
The search that did start on December 23 was thorough given the limited access to volunteers and the investigators made the right decision to search within a radius with an 80 per cent chance of finding the average missing person, Whitehead testified.
However, the search should not have stopped on December 25 in response to a false sighting of Ahfat and did not resume as key reports were not completed.
“Searching should have continued and ultimately that may have altered that outcome here?” Ford said.
“Yes,” Whitehead replied.
Queensland Police had the best search and rescue capability in Australia, Whitehead testified.
A medical adviser to police search and rescue teams found Ahfat most probably died by suicide on December 16, 2022.
“Tallis’s family have different views as to what may have happened,” Ford previously said.
Ahfat’s family members were in court to watch the inquest.
The coroner will also consider evidence that Ahfat met with foul play.
The young man had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia in the years before his disappearance, but he had been stable and taking medication.
However, in the weeks before his disappearance his mental health deteriorated from the stress of multiple personal tragedies and he had started taking methamphetamine again.
Ahfat told a close relative he intended to kill himself, was hearing voices and wanted to “go out bush to clear my head”.
The inquest is due to resume on June 15 in Brisbane.
If you or someone you know needs help, phone Lifeline on 13 11 14, Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636, or 13YARN on 13 92 76.
AAP
